New context menu is worse

[mbiebl]

I don't like the the new context menu where all items are grouped in submenus. A context menu should provide quick access to the most common actions. Take konqueror for example: The context menu provides quick access to the 5-7 most used actions and only moves actions into submenus that are used less often. Good candidates for direct access would be:

Add Delete Revert Diff against head

[niko]

imho the menu is better than before - but not perfect :D

my candidates would be - update - commit - Full Log - Diff against head - Blame(?) and people that use locking will need these items very often.

....so i think everybody will need different items - TortoiseSVN makes it configurable which is a good solution imho

[mbiebl]

Sorry, didn't want to sound so harsh...

- commit - Full Log - Diff against head

I would second that, this points seem reasonable, too. I just wanted to make my point a little bit clearer with my suggestions.

Although I have to admit that I like your first idea (bug #0000020) about dynamic context menus best. So for example unversionied files would only have to have Add and Ignore in their context menu and for versionied files Add could be dropped.

[alwin]

Sorry, didn't want to sound so harsh...

Ah no, you didn't ;)

Well - as said: its hard to implement. I have no idea that moment. Hard that way, which items to select for which state. 'cause listview is multiselectable there are a lot of possible combinations, include that one where items are using EXCLUDING items. eg. some files are unversioned, some must commited, some are stateless (== no changes against repostiorie) and so on.

So I think, I'll should reduce it to up to 5 entries them would always same:

• working copy:
  • update to head
  • commit
  • full log
  • diff
  • blame
• repository:
  • full log
  • checkout current path
  • export current path
  • blame
  • cat head

What about, guys?

[niko]

nice!

all other commands are still avaliable through the toolbar and/or menubar - thats the purpose of a context-menu.

[alwin]

no protests anymore - mark it as fixed.

[DHauptmann]

In version 0.9.2 the 'blame' entry is missing. Bug or Feature?

[alwin]

more a "please don't overload the contextmenu with features" problem. And seems that blaming isn't that used like the other entries. Of course it would nicer having a editor for contextmenus like for toolbars, but this is more a kde "problem".

[viewit]

Ok. no problem. I assign a keyboard shortcut. you can close the problem